Yellowstone: 1883 fans spot glaring historical Elsa Dutton error | TV & Radio | Showbiz & TV

1883 turns back the clocks all the way to the 19th Century, when James (played by Tim McGraw) and Margaret (Faith Hill) became the first Duttons to set foot on the Yellowstone reservation. Unfortunately, a number of people who tuned into last Sunday’s edition of the Paramount Network drama were unimpressed by a strange historical inaccuracy.

Fans have flocked to Twitter to point out a huge anachronism involving the Duttons’ 17-year-old daughter, Elsa (Isabel May).

As the narrator of the series, Elsa joins her parents, and brother John (Audie Rick), as they journey from Texas to Montana with aging cowboy Shea Brenna (Sam Elliott).

So far, the prequel has proven to be both a revealing look at how the powerful Dutton family came to be, as well as an impressive retelling of the American West.

While the show’s period-accurate costumes, locations and dialogue have convinced fans thus far, some of the seams began to show in episode seven, Lightning Yellow Hair.

READ MORE: Coronation Street exit for Phill Whittaker as he’s killed off?

Several viewers took to social media when they realized Isabel’s hair extensions were clearly visible during a pivotal scene.

User @Calypsocooki joked: “How are you gonna have an episode titled specifically on hair and be showing tracks? I’m dying. ”

Although the episode makes reference to Elsa’s striking blonde hair, the costume department apparently did not pay enough attention when covering up Isabel’s modern extensions.

Other fans noticed the error, and accused the series of not staying accurate to the show’s 1883 setting.

Moreover, the clip of one of her hair extensions being on show for all to see during a close-up shot has clearly broken the illusion for a significant portion of the show’s audience.

Paramount viewer Ed Leigh claimed Elsa’s character has been inaccurate throughout the first season.

They explained: “I said from the beginning that for a show thats claims to be authentic, Elsa looks like she was teleported from 1960s Santa Monica to the prairies of the 1880s.

“Women did not wear their hair OR their blouses like she does. I know she’s a free spirit, but it’s very unrealistic. ”

Leave a Comment